Lease vs Buy: What's Better for You? A Complete Comparison

Should you lease or buy your next car? This is one of the most important financial decisions you'll make when acquiring a vehicle, and the right answer depends on your driving habits, financial situation, lifestyle preferences, and long-term goals. Understanding the fundamental differences between leasing and buying, how costs compare over time, and which factors matter most for your situation can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your priorities.

Leasing and buying represent fundamentally different approaches to vehicle ownership. Leasing is essentially a long-term rental where you pay for the vehicle's depreciation during the lease term, while buying means you're financing ownership and will eventually own the vehicle outright. Each option has distinct advantages and disadvantages that make it better suited for different situations.

Leasing in a Nutshell

When you lease a vehicle, you're paying for the right to use it for a specified period (typically 24-36 months) and a set number of miles (usually 10,000-15,000 per year). Your monthly payment covers the vehicle's depreciation over the lease term, plus rent charges (essentially interest), taxes, and fees. At lease end, you return the vehicle or purchase it for the predetermined residual value.

Pros of Leasing:

Lower monthly payments for the same vehicle (typically 20-30% less than financing)
Drive a newer car more frequently with full warranty coverage
No depreciation risk—you're not responsible for the vehicle's value at lease end
Potential tax advantages for business use (consult a tax professional)
No need to sell or trade-in when you're done
Latest safety features and technology more often

Cons of Leasing:

Mileage limits and excess mileage charges (typically $0.15-$0.25 per mile over limit)
Wear-and-tear charges for damage beyond normal use
You never build equity unless you buy the car at lease end
Early termination is costly and restrictive
Limited customization options
Ongoing payments with no ownership at the end
Higher insurance costs in some cases

Buying (Financing) in a Nutshell

When you buy a vehicle through financing, your monthly payment goes toward a loan that eventually results in full ownership. You can drive as much as you want, customize the vehicle, and keep it as long as it's reliable. Once the loan is paid off, you own the vehicle free and clear.

Pros of Buying:

Full ownership after loan payoff
No mileage restrictions or excess mileage fees
Complete flexibility—drive as much as you want, customize freely
Potentially lower total cost over a long ownership period
Build equity as you pay down the loan
Can keep the vehicle payment-free after payoff
No wear-and-tear charges or lease-end fees

Cons of Buying:

Higher monthly payments than comparable leases
You bear depreciation risk if you sell early
Out-of-warranty repair costs as the vehicle ages
Responsible for selling or trading when you're ready for a new vehicle
Less frequent access to newest models and technology

Total Cost Comparison: The Math Matters

While leases offer lower monthly payments, buying often wins on total cost if you keep the vehicle for 6-10 years. The key is understanding total cost of ownership, not just monthly payments.

Leasing Example: $35,000 vehicle, 36-month lease, 12,000 miles/year

Monthly payment: $450
Down payment: $2,500
Acquisition fee: $595
Disposition fee: $395
Total 3-year cost: $19,885
You own nothing at the end

Buying Example: Same $35,000 vehicle, 60-month loan at 6% APR, 20% down

Monthly payment: $541
Down payment: $7,000
Total payments over 5 years: $32,460
Vehicle value after 5 years: ~$15,000
Net cost: $17,460 (plus you own a $15,000 asset)

If you keep the purchased vehicle for 2 more years payment-free:

Total 7-year cost: $32,460
Vehicle value after 7 years: ~$10,000
Net cost: $22,460 vs $44,715 for two leases (roughly)

Use our auto loan calculator to model buying costs, then compare to realistic lease offers including all fees.

Mileage and Driving Habits: The Deciding Factor

Your annual mileage is one of the most important factors in the lease vs buy decision:

If you drive 12,000-15,000 miles/year: Leasing can work well if you stay within limits. Excess mileage charges can quickly erase lease savings.

If you drive more than 15,000 miles/year: Buying typically makes more sense. Excess mileage charges at $0.20/mile add up quickly—10,000 excess miles costs $2,000.

If you drive less than 10,000 miles/year: Leasing may offer good value, but you're paying for miles you don't use. Consider negotiating a lower-mileage lease or buying.

Special Considerations:

Rideshare drivers: Buying is usually better due to high mileage
Frequent long trips: Buying avoids excess mileage charges
Mostly city driving: Either can work, but buying offers more flexibility
Work-from-home: Leasing might make sense if you drive very little

Residual Value and Buyout Decisions

At lease end, you have the option to buy the vehicle for its residual value (predetermined purchase price). This decision requires careful analysis:

When Buyout Makes Sense:

Used car prices are strong and residual value is below market value
You love the vehicle and want to keep it
You've driven it more than expected and excess mileage fees would be high
The vehicle has been reliable and well-maintained

When Returning Makes Sense:

Residual value is above market value
You want a new vehicle
You've exceeded mileage limits significantly
The vehicle has issues or you're ready for something different

Example: Your lease residual is $18,000, but similar vehicles sell for $20,000. Buying and immediately selling could net $2,000 (minus taxes and fees). However, if you want to keep driving it, compare the buyout price to similar used vehicles—you might get a better deal buying elsewhere.

Credit, Cash Flow, and Financial Priorities

Your financial situation significantly impacts the lease vs buy decision:

Credit Requirements: Leases typically require stronger credit (often 700+) to access the best rates. If your credit is fair, buying may offer more options.

Cash Flow: If monthly cash flow is tight, leasing's lower payments can improve affordability. However, you're trading long-term cost for short-term relief.

Down Payment: Leases often require down payments (capitalized cost reduction), though $0 down leases exist. Buying typically requires 10-20% down for best terms.

Long-term Cost Priority: If minimizing total cost is your priority, buying and keeping the vehicle long-term usually wins. Leasing is a lifestyle choice that prioritizes lower payments and newer vehicles.

Investment Opportunity: If you can invest the difference between lease and buy payments at returns exceeding your loan APR, leasing might make mathematical sense—though this involves risk.

Real-World Example: Lease vs Buy Decision

Sarah is considering a $35,000 SUV. She drives 12,000 miles/year and plans to keep a vehicle for 5 years.

Lease Option:

36-month lease: $450/month, $2,500 down
Total 3-year cost: $19,885
Then lease again for 2 years: $475/month, $2,500 down
Total 5-year cost: $31,220
No vehicle ownership at the end

Buy Option:

60-month loan at 6%: $541/month, $7,000 down
Total 5-year cost: $32,460
Vehicle value after 5 years: ~$15,000
Net cost: $17,460
Own a $15,000 asset

Sarah chooses buying because she values ownership and lower long-term cost. The higher monthly payment is manageable, and she'll own a valuable asset after 5 years.

When Leasing Makes Sense

Leasing is ideal when:

You want a new vehicle every 2-3 years
You drive predictable, moderate mileage (under 15,000/year)
You prefer lower monthly payments
You want the latest safety features and technology
You use the vehicle for business (potential tax benefits)
You don't want to deal with selling/trading vehicles
You can stay within mileage and wear limits

When Buying Makes Sense

Buying is better when:

You drive more than 15,000 miles/year
You want to minimize long-term costs
You prefer to own your vehicle outright
You want to customize or modify your vehicle
You plan to keep the vehicle 5+ years
You have moderate credit (leasing requires stronger credit)
You value flexibility in mileage and usage

Negotiating a Lease

If you decide to lease, negotiate these key terms:

Capitalized Cost (Cap Cost): The vehicle's purchase price—negotiate this like you would when buying. Lower cap cost means lower payments.

Money Factor: The lease equivalent of interest rate. Lower is better. Multiply by 2,400 to approximate APR equivalent.

Residual Value: Higher residual means lower payments, but you pay more if you buy at lease end. This is often set by the manufacturer, but you can compare offers.

Mileage Allowance: Negotiate higher mileage limits upfront if needed—it's cheaper than paying excess mileage fees later.

Fees: Negotiate acquisition fees, disposition fees, and other charges. Some are negotiable, others are set by the manufacturer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I negotiate a lease?

Yes. Negotiate the capitalized cost (selling price), money factor (interest rate), and fees. The residual value is typically set by the manufacturer, but you can compare offers from different dealers.

Is a lease ever cheaper long-term?

Rarely. Buying and keeping a vehicle longer generally yields the lowest lifetime cost. Leasing is a lifestyle choice that prioritizes lower payments and newer vehicles over long-term cost savings.

What happens if I exceed mileage limits?

You'll pay excess mileage charges, typically $0.15-$0.25 per mile over your limit. On a 36-month lease with 12,000 miles/year, exceeding by 5,000 miles costs $750-$1,250. This can quickly erase lease savings.

Can I get out of a lease early?

Early lease termination is costly. You're responsible for remaining payments minus the vehicle's current value, plus fees. Some leases allow transfers to qualified buyers, which can be less costly than early termination.

Should I buy my leased vehicle?

Compare the residual value to similar used vehicles. If residual is below market value and you want to keep it, buying makes sense. If residual is above market value, returning is usually better.

Related Guides

Sources

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. "Leasing vs Buying a Vehicle: What to Consider."
Federal Trade Commission. "Vehicle Leasing: Understanding the Basics."
National Automobile Dealers Association. "Lease vs Buy: Making the Right Choice."

Try our Free Auto Loan Calculator →

Formula Forge